For the last 6 years or so, I have believed that the majority of Christians in the music industry need to be creating 1 of 2 types of music.
First, there is music for the church, for the intent of singing along with in worship.
Secondly, there is music for everyone--Christian or not--that has a meaning for those who aren't followers of Christ, and then a deeper meaning for those who are believers.
I heard an interview with the "Christian band" Sanctus Real, where they said they really felt called to build up the church through their music, even after they had won a mainstream talent search contest in the Midwest. So I respect that a small percentage of Christian musicians should be making what is traditionally known as "Christian music." There is value to being edified through music and good, Christian lyrics (notice the comma between "good" and "Christian;" these are separate values).
___________________________________________
The last 24 hours have filled my head with thoughts about the role of Christians in the music industry.
Last night we talked about justice at our small group, and afterwards, I was left pondering the value of Christians creating music for entertainment's sake when there are far more important issues, e.g. putting food on the tables of the thousands of people who are starving all around the world. I didn't come to any conclusions about that thought.
____________________________________________
Another realization I had today is that Christians are starting to make an impact on the mainstream music industry in new genres. For the last 4 or 5 years, we've seen a huge exodus in the rock and alternative genres, as most of the talented Christians prefer to make good music for everyone. When I was on the Big Island, we were listening to a rock station, and in a span of 8 songs (about a half hour of radio programming), every other song was by a band whose members have at one point stated they are Christians (Chevelle, Mute Math, Paramore, and there was one more that I forget).
Obviously, bands like P.O.D., Switchfoot, Relient K, dc Talk, etc. have been crossing over into the mainstream (or the Myriad). But now, I'm realizing that pop artists are too. Some did a long time ago, but others are more successful now. For example, we have Kelly Clarkson, Mat Kearney, Lifehouse (which I could have put in the rock section, and Switchfoot could also go here), The Fray, Carrie Underwood (I guess she's "pop" enough that I can count her as part of this new phenomena and not just as part of the normal Christian-ness in country), and more.
__________________________________________
Today I was listening to the radio, and I heard that Natasha Bedingfield song "Love Like This." I found out a few months ago that she used to be involved with the Hillsong London worship albums, and I'd heard a few years earlier that she and her brother Daniel Bedingfield (who was famous for about a year in 2003) were strong Christians. Then in the December/January issue of Relevant Magazine, they had an interview with her talking about how her belief in Jesus changes everything about who she is and what she sings about. I've also noticed that the themes of her lyrics are pretty much the opposite of most popular R&B songs.
I've seen the video for "Love Like This," and Sean Kingston sings a bridge in it that doesn't really fit with the song. I'm not positive about this, but the
lyrics seem to be talking about Jesus, not some regular guy that she has been in love with for years. Except, the Sean Kingston part is definitely about a guy and a girl.
Well, today I heard the song on the radio and the the Sean Kingston part wasn't there, leading me to believe that the parts of the song she wrote are about Jesus, while the part he wrote isn't.
Check out the 2nd verse, for instance...
All the guys tried to take me, you’re the one who saved me,I feel like I owe you my life.And as strange as it may seem, I’ll go if you take meI'm willing to sacrifice.
"You're the one who saved me," and "I'll go if you take me/I'm willing to sacrifice" sound like Christian statements of the best type.
So, I don't know if that was the meaning of the song or not, but I bet this is an example of a Christian writing a song with 2 meanings. Like C.S. Lewis or J.R.R. Tolkien writing just-plain-good fiction on one level, with tons of allegorical allusions snuck in for the Christians who read it.
I read an interview a few years ago with either Lewis or Tolkien (I forget) where they said something to the effect of "we're trying to be sneaky." That's a major paraphrase, but it stated the fact that Christian references in art should be so hidden, but so obvious.
____________________________________________
In
Colossians 2:2-3, Paul says the purpose of his writing is (in part), "...that they may know the mystery of God, namely, Christ,
in whom are hidden all the treasures of wisdom and knowledge."
My dad read this verse at our staff meeting earlier today, and I was struck by the idea of knowing the mystery, when the mystery is that all wisdom and knowledge are hidden in Christ. So you know something, and what you know is that everything is hidden.
Cool paradox.
So, that kind of supports the work of Christians in the realm of the arts who try to sneak Jesus in to their work. It should be revealed and hidden. It's a paradox. That's what makes it beautiful.
One thing we decided at our staff meeting today is that the music we play after church should be lyrical. Before church it's instrumental and cranked up pretty loud. We've started doing this, because we noticed that people do that at concerts/sporting events, and it helps foster a sense of excitement. It's worked quite well in the month that we've tried it. People are ready to start, but the bustle of conversations is also more evident.
But after church, we decided that we would focus on playing "secular" music by Christians. That way, we teach a few important lessons.
1. To the people who only listen to Christian music, we teach that there is no "Christian music." There are Christians, and if they make music that is good, that's awesome. But it's not so controversial to be playing music by non-Christians after church.
2. To the people who think Christian music is poor quality, we teach that a lot of the music they already listen to was performed and/or written by Christians.
3. We show all people how some others are "being salt and light in the world," and encourage them to do the same using whatever talents and abilities they have.
Whew. That was a long one.